MLB The Show 25 has just been released, and if you’re on the hunt for the top hitters in the game, you’ve come to the right place. Understanding who excels at hitting can significantly enhance your team selection for Franchise mode, help you pick cards for your Diamond Dynasty squad, or simply inform your strategy about who to intentionally walk when they come to bat. In baseball, scoring at least one run is essential to win a game; therefore, having a strong slugger on your roster is crucial.
This year’s edition of MLB The Show 25 introduces some new hitting mechanics, including the Ambush Hitting feature, which allows players to anticipate the next pitch. While you’re learning these new techniques, it might be beneficial to practice with some of the league’s elite hitters. Although various teams are represented among the top hitters, it’s no surprise to see certain names appearing more than once.
Top Hitters in MLB The Show 25
Notable World Series Champions in the Rankings
Leading the pack in MLB The Show 25 is Shohei Ohtani, challenging the outdated notion that pitchers can’t hit well. Despite not pitching in 2024 due to an injury, Ohtani maintained an impressive .310 batting average throughout the regular season, slightly exceeding his career average. With a .333 batting average in Spring Training, he looks poised for continued success in the 2025 season.
The hitters with the highest overall ratings (OVR) in MLB The Show 25 are:
- Shohei Ohtani – 99
- Juan Soto (NYM) – 99
- Aaron Judge – 99
- Ketel Marte – 96
- Bobby Witt Jr. – 96
- José Ramírez – 95
- Mike Trout – 95
- Mookie Betts – 95
- Francisco Lindor – 95
- Bryce Harper – 95
Interestingly, although Ohtani tops the list, Aaron Judge, also rated at 99, had superior statistics in several areas during the 2024 season. Judge boasted a higher batting average of .322 and recorded more home runs and RBIs, even with fewer at-bats compared to Ohtani. However, Judge’s performance in Spring Training this year wasn’t as impressive, which may influence their rankings.
Another name to note is Juan Soto of the New York Mets. Despite having a marginally lower batting average and OPS than Ohtani and Judge, Soto had an outstanding season in 2024 and is currently performing well in Spring Training. This could lead to a shift in rankings as the 2025 season approaches.
Teams Featuring the Best Hitters
Several Teams with Multiple Top 10 Hitters
While multiple teams appear in the rankings of top hitters for MLB The Show 25, a few have made the list more than once. Unsurprisingly, both the 2024 World Series champion LA Dodgers and the New York Mets have two players represented in the top ten. Any of these teams would be excellent choices for anyone looking to play Franchise mode and build a team around powerful hitters.
The leading teams for hitters in MLB The Show 25 are:
- LA Dodgers
- New York Mets
- New York Yankees
- Arizona Diamondbacks
- Kansas City Royals
- Cleveland Guardians
- LA Angels
- Philadelphia Phillies
While hitting isn’t everything in MLB The Show 25, it’s advantageous to build a team with a roster full of capable sluggers to help secure a lead. Moreover, players’ cards in Diamond Dynasty mode are worth tracking. Remember, your skill level also plays a significant role in how well players perform, so effective gameplay is possible even if your hitting lineup isn’t fully optimized.
